Eternal Duel

URL: http://eternalduel.darkbb.com

type: ALL

This time i would like joel to review the site cause my members like the way he looks at things and I want to see what he thinks this time.
some of the updates below were not included the last time joel reviewed my site
~ Forums Added:

• Duel Gangs
  
• Gang War Zone
  
• Deck Help
  
• Card Q&A
  
• Trading
  
• Yu-Gi-Oh! games
  
• Duel stories
  
• Duel Requests (sidebar only)
  
• Contests (sidebar only)
  
• Deck Garage (sidebar only)
  

~ New Group: Teachers
~ New Group: Duel Referee
~ more members than last time
~ Don't forget to comment on gallery like you did last time
~ Don't forget about the favicon either
~ We got a side bar now so.... yeah
~ Portal is a little different now =D
~ 60 videos in the episode page now =D
~ New images for 'Locked', 'Post Reply', & 'New Topic' (visit an unlocked post for 2 of them & a locked post for da other)


Remember, it is common for yugioh forums to have AT LEAST 3-4 groups that REQUIRE a TEST. So there isn't any reason to downgrade me on that. look at some of the forums in the link below if you don't believe me...

https://www.forumotion.com/en/art-culture-and-leisures/yugioh-400.htm
look at the forums here and see how many have at least 3 groups that need a test for proof. cause i dont want to be downgraded for something that is common in yugioh forums

Tagged

Will get this done in the next 72 hours or less!

thanks buddy =D

Generalities

1. First Impressions-15/15
Congrats on your new loading page once again:) Maybe you should put up a poll if your members wanted the loading page as they'll have to wait longer than usual this way. I have also noticed ALOT of new forums added. I'll get on with this soon.
2. Categories & Forums-13/15
New forums. As stated you have added the forums

• Duel Gangs
  
• Gang War Zone
  
• Deck Help
  
• Card
  Q&A
  
• Trading
  
• Yu-Gi-Oh! games
  
• Duel
  stories
  
• Duel Requests (sidebar only)
  
• Contests
  (sidebar only)
  
• Deck Garage (sidebar only)
  

Well, i disagree with this a little. You should'nt go too far on adding too much forums! It makes it all messy and ugly again. But i also noticed your forum overall length have'nt changed. Did you add the forums to other categories? Anyway, forums like Yugiyoh games, duel stories and contests should be all crunched up together as it is'nt that important. Providing more categories and forums for your members is good. But too much, of course its bad.

Generalities total :: 28/30

Forum Style

1. Major Graphics-8/10
Improved on graphics. I like your loading page image. I would agree on the whole blue color. Noticed your new "card" favicon:) Unique and cool! All the new posts, no new posts and forum is locked images is suitable and fits well:) Maybe you could just resize them a little to make it even nicer:)
2. Forum Layout & Color Scheme-8/10
New skin as i mentioned in your previous review. Color fits well. But like i said again, try a new skin:) Maybe i could go around Hitskin.com helping you find better ones than your current one. I would go for a much fresher look and not so dark colored one.
3.Images & Icons-8/10
New images:) Well, somehow i like you "girl" images now. But i suggest you resize them just quite a bit. Other than that, good job.

Forum Style total :: 24/30

Usergroups

1.Population of Groups-7/10
Yea, about the same. Nothing much to say here. I noticed 2 new groups! Teachers and Duel Referee.
2.Staff Groups / User Groups-6/10
Well, you told me its common for those "test groups" and gee, i guess you're right. But you can try being different by not having it;) Anyway, i noticed no new groups. Keep it clean and tidy:)

Usergroups total :: 13/20

Forum Activity

1. Post/Member Ratio & Quantity-10/10
Our users have posted a total of 5188 messages
We have 33 registered users
Oh boy, here we go again! And one more thing, your forum is rapidly growing!
2. Users Active-7/10
Members connected during last 24 hours : aurora, BlackRoseWicth, duelistwinner, greendragon, Ice Drakus, jaden123, Jesse Anderson, Joey, sasuke19965, Tsunadesama16, uncommon2, VampirePikapal, whisper (13 members) i made all your connected members in red to look at it easier:) An increase? A little. But keep it up!

Forum Activity total ::17/20

Overall Marks

82/100 Congrats!You passed! New record set!

The Conclusion

Noticed a bunch of new members! Rapidly growing! Good luck and keep it up! Grats on your new review record for Eternal Duel too:)

30 BoilingPoints deducted.

woot!!!

dont forget to post this on eternal duel for others to see =D

One problem, I mentioned 2 new groups above... Teachers and Duel Referee... please edit for that

Done;)

thanks =D