review
+3
Joel
techguy1001
.mouse.pad.
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
review
Forum URL: http://www.wickedpenman.gway.info
Request Type: full
Extra Notes:Could Cafetin please do this?
Request Type: full
Extra Notes:Could Cafetin please do this?
Re: review
Could I do it instead please? I'm on trial and I've been waiting for a review for a while now.
Re: review
Mousepad, i don't think Cafetin, as administrator here, have the time to do this. Why not let our trail reviewers take this?
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: review
Fred100 wrote:You can also not backseat mod.
~Avian
What do you mean? I didn't -- i don't think...
Avian wrote:I say let tecchy do it.
Thanks! I'll do it by tomorrow
Re: review
Woah hold on Tech, he was backseat moderating so I edited. You have to wait for mousepad's approval first.
Avian- Banned
-
1112
756
20
2010-02-15
27
..I'm dead..
Re: review
I have to step in now.
No one is to reply to this topic until Mousepad does.
No one is to reply to this topic until Mousepad does.
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: review
Wicked Penman
Generalities Related: (30 Marks)
- Spoiler:
- The generalities, were all nearly excellent.I liked how all the forums were placed in right categories. Just wondering , what's "Awnie"? in "Hey, I'm Awnie and am new to the forum!". It's pretty obvious that it's a introductory forum , but yeah what does awnie stand for? & I liked the description for "Help Center" (If you're drowning, I'm very sorry but we can't help you.) pretty much made me smile. I Liked how each forum/category is been named and placed. The Grammar's perfect. I loved it. Keep up the Good grammar and the humor!
Therefore with what I concluded & would rate is ,
30/30
Graphic Designs: (30 Marks)
- Spoiler:
- The graphics on the forums were really nice . The Banner's was great. I liked how the words were chosen to represent "Wicked Penman". Everything matched the theme, the background and the colors. I wasn't much impressed with the the New post in a forum icons, But the topic icons....they were great! I liked them even though I just visited the forum as a guest . But yeah topic icons were great . Just a suggestion , the current theme over there...Black & White..Doesn't seems nice. Try some different colour combination which won't hurt the eyes of visitors & would look pretty nice for a forum which is sort of related to talent of the users
Therefore with what I concluded & would rate is ,
27/30
Forum Activity/Population: (20 Marks)
- Spoiler:
- Considering your forum is nearly brand new , I can't really put up some comments yet. But one thing which I can suggest you is , try some competetions. Or try to motivate your forum users to post more!
Users have posted a total of 615 messages
Total amount of 17 registered users
Something which I've been doing so far is this ,
Total amount of posts / Total amount of users...and in your case was ,
615/17 = 36.1764705882352941%
As I said before because your forum's new , so it hardly matters
But yeah 36 is a really nice count though
Therefore what I concluded & would rate is ,
17/20
User Groups: (20 Marks)
- Spoiler:
- As I saw the usergroups were as following ,
Administrators, Bots & Global moderators.
I don't think you people will need much groups...So it's alright
Even though , because you guys only have a little amount of traffic.
Therefore what I concluded & would rate is ,
13/20
Total Score: 87/100 Nice job! You passed and have done a brilliant job!
All you guys need for now is activity
So why not try advertising your forum over AH? Bet that would help
Wanna share your forum review? Copy the code and paste it in!
- Code:
[center][img]http://i37.tinypic.com/qnu1bq.jpg[/img]
[color=darkblue][size=18][b]Wicked Penman[/b][/size][/color]
[i][color=darkblue]Generalities Related: (30 Marks)[/color][/i][/center]
[spoiler]The generalities, were all nearly excellent.I liked how all the forums were placed in right categories. Just wondering , what's "Awnie"? in "Hey, I'm Awnie and am new to the forum!". It's pretty obvious that it's a introductory forum , but yeah what does awnie stand for? & I liked the description for "Help Center" (If you're drowning, I'm very sorry but we can't help you.) pretty much made me smile. I Liked how each forum/category is been named and placed. The Grammar's perfect. I loved it. Keep up the Good grammar and the humor! ;)
[color=darkblue]Therefore with what I concluded & would rate is ,
30/30[/color][/spoiler]
[center]
[color=darkcyan][i]Graphic Designs: (30 Marks)[/i][/color][/center]
[spoiler]The graphics on the forums were really nice :). The Banner's was great. I liked how the words were chosen to represent "Wicked Penman". Everything matched the theme, the background and the colors. I wasn't much impressed with the the New post in a forum icons, But the topic icons....they were great! I liked them even though I just visited the forum as a guest :P. But yeah topic icons were great ;). Just a suggestion , the current theme over there...Black & White..Doesn't seems nice. Try some different colour combination which won't hurt the eyes of visitors & would look pretty nice for a forum which is sort of related to talent of the users :)
[color=darkcyan]Therefore with what I concluded & would rate is ,
27/30[/color][/spoiler]
[center][color=darkred][i]Forum Activity/Population: (20 Marks)[/i][/color][/center]
[spoiler]Considering your forum is nearly brand new , I can't really put up some comments yet. But one thing which I can suggest you is , try some competetions. Or try to motivate your forum users to post more!
Users have posted a total of 615 messages
Total amount of 17 registered users
Something which I've been doing so far is this ,
Total amount of posts / Total amount of users...and in your case was ,
615/17 = 36.1764705882352941%
As I said before because your forum's new , so it hardly matters ;)
But yeah 36 is a really nice count though :)
[color=darkred]Therefore what I concluded & would rate is ,
16/20[/color][/spoiler]
[center][color=darkgreen][i]User Groups: (20 Marks)[/i][/color][/center]
[spoiler]As I saw the usergroups were as following ,
Administrators, Bots & Global moderators.
I don't think you people will need much groups...So it's alright ;)
Even though , because you guys only have a little amount of traffic.
[color=darkgreen]Therefore what I concluded & would rate is ,
13/20[/color][/spoiler]
[b]Total Score:[/b] 87/100 Nice job! You passed and have done a brilliant job!
[img]http://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_arrow.gif[/img] All you guys need for now is activity ;)
So why not try advertising your forum over AH? Bet that would help ;)
Re: review
Not bad Fred.
30 BP taken.
Completed.
Also thanks for asking for me mouse. Unfortunately I was on a one week vacation. That`s why I could not respond before. Just got back.
Anyway, I`ve taken out my name from the title cause it`s a little misguiding like this. Hope you don`t mind.
30 BP taken.
Completed.
Also thanks for asking for me mouse. Unfortunately I was on a one week vacation. That`s why I could not respond before. Just got back.
Anyway, I`ve taken out my name from the title cause it`s a little misguiding like this. Hope you don`t mind.
Cafetin- Administrator Team
-
1735
2909
39
2010-03-04
37
Serbia
Similar topics
» review me
» The Blitzkampf-Another review(this time, do the review.)
» Review again
» SOD Review (2)
» Review please
» The Blitzkampf-Another review(this time, do the review.)
» Review again
» SOD Review (2)
» Review please
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum