Review.........?
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
Re: Review.........?
the template.
actually, there is nothing wrong. Just the template questions.
Nevermind.
actually, there is nothing wrong. Just the template questions.
Nevermind.
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: Review.........?
ok then................... btw since its only half the review things is it half price??? just a question it doesnt really matter...
(im tired?)
(im tired?)
Re: Review.........?
for brief reviews, it will cost 15 BoilingPoints, for full reviews, it will cost 30 BoilingPoints.
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: Review.........?
Alright. Your review is the next in line now. Please be patient. Thanks.
Cafetin- Administrator Team
-
1735
2909
39
2010-03-04
37
Serbia
Re: Review.........?
This review is in progress and will be done by Cafetin
Thanks for your kind patience.
Thanks for your kind patience.
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: Review.........?
I hope this is the brief review. I reviewed only the style of your forum.
"Nothing is personal in a review"
My rating table (Style only):
36-40 - Unexpectedly Awesome
31-35 - Awesome
24-30 - Pretty Nice
16-23 - Average
8-15 - Below Average
0-8 - Fail
"Nothing is personal in a review"
My rating table (Style only):
36-40 - Unexpectedly Awesome
31-35 - Awesome
24-30 - Pretty Nice
16-23 - Average
8-15 - Below Average
0-8 - Fail
Graphics:
- Theme: A simple theme with simple colors and fonttype. Generally good. But when I first looked into a post, I almost gave up trying to find the users statistics after a half hour. Yeah, it was on the left and the avatars are on the right. I think it is a better solution when you can see every detail in one place. My second shock was when I saw that there is some image verification code below the "Quick Reply" box. Did you put that thing up for every member or just guests? Cause it can be annoying in my opinion. I suggest you to remove it. A better experience was when I saw the "Inventory". No pokemon forum can exist without one. Just fill it up with some more items. (7/10)
- Banner: Nice one. I don`t know which pokemon is that but somehow I like it. But I have to mention two things. First is about the background. The perspective is not made how it is supposed to be. Those green-brown blurred brushes are too blurred but it seems as if they are closer to the point of view. Maybe because they are big. Either way, it should be a little more sharper than the mountain on the left side. On second thought... Maybe that pokemon is a small one and the picture was "taken" from the short grass around it. If that is the case, just ignore the previous few sentences. Second is the text itself. It should stand out from the picture making it really visible. Put some effects on it. Maybe a glow around it or a stroke with some shadow effect. That`s it. (6/10)
- Navigation Bar: That is pretty basic. Small icons with text on the right side. Not my type. Too simple. I would suggest you to change them with some real buttons. (5/10)
- Icons: Spheres with arrows and locks. Matching the forum theme but not so original. The topic icons like the "New Thread", "New Post" and "Locked" are really nice, but again, I think it is the default for the theme (I could be wrong, though). The "Hot Thread (New/No New)" and such are the same thing. Try to bring some originality into your forum. It can mean much. Also why don`t you put up some icons for the items in the inventory too? That would be a nice addition too. (6/10)
The sum of all is 24/40. Pretty Nice considering the fact that there is not much originality. Either hire some graphic designers or make some pictures yourself.
Note that I am not only rating the pictures here. If you have your own pictures used in your forum, that is a plus point right in the beginning from me.
- Theme: A simple theme with simple colors and fonttype. Generally good. But when I first looked into a post, I almost gave up trying to find the users statistics after a half hour. Yeah, it was on the left and the avatars are on the right. I think it is a better solution when you can see every detail in one place. My second shock was when I saw that there is some image verification code below the "Quick Reply" box. Did you put that thing up for every member or just guests? Cause it can be annoying in my opinion. I suggest you to remove it. A better experience was when I saw the "Inventory". No pokemon forum can exist without one. Just fill it up with some more items. (7/10)
- Banner: Nice one. I don`t know which pokemon is that but somehow I like it. But I have to mention two things. First is about the background. The perspective is not made how it is supposed to be. Those green-brown blurred brushes are too blurred but it seems as if they are closer to the point of view. Maybe because they are big. Either way, it should be a little more sharper than the mountain on the left side. On second thought... Maybe that pokemon is a small one and the picture was "taken" from the short grass around it. If that is the case, just ignore the previous few sentences. Second is the text itself. It should stand out from the picture making it really visible. Put some effects on it. Maybe a glow around it or a stroke with some shadow effect. That`s it. (6/10)
- Navigation Bar: That is pretty basic. Small icons with text on the right side. Not my type. Too simple. I would suggest you to change them with some real buttons. (5/10)
- Icons: Spheres with arrows and locks. Matching the forum theme but not so original. The topic icons like the "New Thread", "New Post" and "Locked" are really nice, but again, I think it is the default for the theme (I could be wrong, though). The "Hot Thread (New/No New)" and such are the same thing. Try to bring some originality into your forum. It can mean much. Also why don`t you put up some icons for the items in the inventory too? That would be a nice addition too. (6/10)
The sum of all is 24/40. Pretty Nice considering the fact that there is not much originality. Either hire some graphic designers or make some pictures yourself.
Note that I am not only rating the pictures here. If you have your own pictures used in your forum, that is a plus point right in the beginning from me.
Cafetin- Administrator Team
-
1735
2909
39
2010-03-04
37
Serbia
Re: Review.........?
Great job Cafetin! Your "brief" review is my full review!
Anyway, 15 BoilingPoints deducted
Anyway, 15 BoilingPoints deducted
Joel- Founder
-
11220
15338
73
2009-12-16
27
Singapore
Re: Review.........?
Joel wrote:Great job Cafetin! Your "brief" review is my full review!
Thanks for the compliment.
As there is no response from the requester, I will close this.
So it is locked.
Cafetin- Administrator Team
-
1735
2909
39
2010-03-04
37
Serbia
Similar topics
» Review please
» The Blitzkampf-Another review(this time, do the review.)
» Review please
» Review again
» SOD Review (2)
» The Blitzkampf-Another review(this time, do the review.)
» Review please
» Review again
» SOD Review (2)
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum